How to Trust Yourself: Breaking Free from the Cycle of Second-Guessing

Have you ever noticed that your first instinct is often right—but you still change your answer? Recently, while preparing for my professional exam, I realized something powerful: 98% of the time, my first answers were correct. Yet, I kept second-guessing myself and switching to the wrong choice. That left me asking, Why do I keep doing this when I’m right?

This isn’t just about exams. It’s about life. Many of us struggle with an internal block that keeps us from trusting ourselves. Let’s unpack why this happens and how to overcome it.


Why We Second-Guess Ourselves

Second-guessing is rooted in fear and self-doubt. Here are some common reasons:

  1. Fear of Failure
    We think, “What if I’m wrong?” That fear pushes us to overanalyze and override our intuition.
  2. Perfectionism
    When we believe we must be flawless, we assume our first thought can’t possibly be good enough.
  3. Conditioning
    Society often teaches us to seek external validation—teachers, bosses, peers—so we learn to distrust our own judgment.
  4. Overthinking
    Our brain loves to complicate things. Instead of trusting the knowledge we’ve worked hard to build, we spiral into “what if” scenarios.

The Truth About Your First Instinct

Research shows that your first answer is usually your best answer—especially when you’ve prepared. That initial response comes from your subconscious, which has processed all the information you’ve learned. When you second-guess, you’re letting fear override logic.


How to Start Trusting Yourself

  1. Recognize the Pattern
    Awareness is the first step. Notice when you’re changing answers or doubting decisions.
  2. Pause Before You Switch
    Ask yourself: Why am I changing this? Is it based on evidence or fear?
  3. Build Confidence Through Preparation
    The more you study or practice, the more you can trust that your instincts are informed.
  4. Affirm Your Knowledge
    Use affirmations like: I trust my first instinct. I’ve prepared for this moment.
  5. Practice Self-Compassion
    Even if you make a mistake, it doesn’t define you. Trust grows when you allow yourself to learn without judgment.

The Bigger Lesson

Second-guessing isn’t just an exam habit—it’s a life habit. Every time you override your intuition, you chip away at self-trust. But when you start honoring your first instinct, you unlock confidence, clarity, and success.

So next time you feel the urge to change an answer—or a decision—pause and remind yourself:
You’ve got this. Your first instinct is powerful. Trust it.

Joy Junkie! Don’t forget to like, share and subscribe! If you love it, somebody else will love it too!

Leave a comment

I’m Kenisha

Welcome to Joy Wasted with KB Dickey, my cozy corner of the internet dedicated to joy as a lifestyle. Here, I invite you to join me on a journey of life hacks, wisdom, and all things related to turning lemons into joy!

One-Time
Monthly
Yearly

If my content has inspired or helped you, consider donating to keep it going. Every contribution helps me continue sharing insights and creating valuable content for you. Your support means the world! It’s 100% optional. Make a one-time donation

Spread joy through giving! If you appreciate this blog, kindly consider a monthly donation to support content creation. Your generosity fuels our mission. However, whether you give or not, you’re always welcome here. Keep reading and enjoying!

Spread joy through giving! If you appreciate this blog, kindly consider a yearly donation to support content creation. Your generosity fuels our mission. However, whether you give or not, you’re always welcome here. Keep reading and enjoying! 100% optional

Choose an amount

$5.00
$15.00
$100.00
$5.00
$15.00
$100.00
$5.00
$15.00
$100.00

Or enter a custom amount

$

Your contribution is appreciated. I am thankful!

Your contribution is appreciated.

Your contribution is appreciated.

DonateDonate monthlyDonate yearly

Let’s connect